Friday, October 28, 2022

13 Nights of Shocktober: My Best Friend's Exorcism

 by A.J.

Night 10: Teenage Horror Night
"Dollars to donuts it's demonic possession."
This is a nice blend of horror and comedy though it leans firmly towards comedy. It 
might not be exactly scary, but it is fun. The story begins as more of a light comedy about teenagers Abby and Gretchen, best friends despite their different socio-economic backgrounds. Gretchen (Amiah Miller) is from a well-to-do family. Abby (Elsie Fisher) attends their private parochial school on scholarship. Gretchen's family is preparing to move and that makes Abby anxious about their future as friends and her future without Gretchen by her side. 
Those concerns get pushed to the background after a terrifying night in the woods. Along with their friends Glee (Cathy Ang) and Margaret (Rachel Ogechi Kanu), and Margaret's obnoxious boyfriend, Wallace (Clayton Johnson), they take LSD, but Abby and Gretchen wander into a dilapidated cabin, rumored to be haunted. Gretchen is attacked by someone, or some thing, but they are not sure what was a hallucination and what was real. 
After the attack, Gretchen's behavior changes and this is when the movie switches gears to horror. At first Gretchen is withdrawn and strung out, then she seems to gain confidence and a new mean personality. The change in her personality and the cruel, hurtful acts she inflicts on her friends happen gradually and believably in scenes that add tension and the supernatural, specifically demonic possession to the story. The final act, that is the exorcism, is horror-comedy and even gets goofy thanks to Christopher Lowell as Christian Lemon, the youth minister bodybuilder performing the exorcism. This gear switch will either work for you or it won't. By this point I cared enough about the characters to want to see their story through and hoped things worked out for them (you can never tell with horror, even a horror comedy). The few scenes with special effects are well done. One CGI effect in particular is as strange as it is grotesque.
Setting this story in the 1980’s is not exactly a weakness but it is unnecessary. There are the benefits that a pre-internet and pre-cellphone time period affords a horror movie and Abby and Gretchen would have more of a challenge remaining in touch if one of them moved away, but the 80’s setting seems mostly for superficial throwback nostalgia. Also, none of the characters speak or act like teens from the 1980's (except for Wallace, whose gross sex-obsessed dialogue is spot on for that kind of character). However, aside from the soundtrack, the other elements of the film (script, production design, costumes) do not revel in nostalgia. The epilogue cards for each character at the end of the movie, are probably the most blatantly 80’s throwback element, but they fit with the movie’s fun nature. 
Elsie Fisher and Amiah Miller have great chemistry and their performances are the highlight and greatest strength of the movie. Fisher is great as the shy and meek Abby, who has such a big heart she can never fully give up on her friend. The real tension of the exorcism is how she is going to stand up to an evil demon and save her friend. Amiah Miller does a good job of playing Gretchen at every stage: good natured teen, a person in distress, and demon possessed. 
My Best Friend's Exorcism belongs in the same vein as the meta-horror movies Happy Death Day and Freaky (Christopher Landon, the director of those movies, is a producer here), though it lacks the self-awareness that helped make those movies so much fun. Here, the fun comes mainly from the performances and a willingness to be silly in certain scenes. Director Damon Thomas and writer Jenna Lamia, adapting the Quirk Books published novel by Grady Hendrix) have made a movie that is most of all about friendship and that is why it works no matter the genre. 

My Best Friend's Exorcism is streaming on Amazon Prime Video.

No comments:

Post a Comment