Action's Top Dogs

by Lani
Safe starring Jason Statham opens in theaters this weekend. Statham is one of my favorite action stars, despite the fact that his films tend to vary wildly in quality. I like that Statham doesn't seem to take himself too seriously. He has a great comedic instincts, as well as convincing physical capabilities. Do I want to see his Hamlet? Not really. Do I want to see him crash a car through a production of Hamlet and proceed to kick everyone's ass? Yes, yes I do.
Judging from early reviews, Safe seems to be a middling entry in the Statham filmography--not quite reaching the heights of Crank, but not as dire as In the Name of the King: A Dungeon Siege Tale. However, there is no question that Statham is currently one of cinema's top dogs when it comes to action films. But who are the other top dogs and underdogs, old and new? Here's a sampling based on the films currently in theaters.

Sam Worthington - Wrath of the Titans
Worthington should be a top dog, judging by his abundance of film roles over the past 2 years, including the highest grossing film of all time, Avatar. However, audiences don't seem to be very enthusiastic about him. (Anecdotal evidence has revealed that some people can't even remember what he looks like, even while staring at his photo.) He has the physicality for action roles, but his flat expression and delivery make him boring and forgettable. A native of Australia, Worthington has been cast as an American, Israeli, robot, and Greek demi-god; perhaps if he were allowed to play an Australian character for once he would not have the burden of keeping up a foreign accent and could then reallocate some megabytes toward facial expressions.

Guy Pearce - Lockout
Pearce is an old dog who has learned some new tricks, and been to the gym. His most recognizable roles so far (Memento, L.A. Confidential) are detectives who rely on intellect rather than physical prowess. However, as ex-CIA agent Snow in Lockout, Pearce plays a wry and resourceful action hero in the style of Escape From New York's Snake Plissken...and he pulls it off! Lockout is a lot of fun, so I would definitely be onboard for the further adventures of Snow. Snake got a sequel, so what's next for Snow? Breaking out of prison on Mars?

Liam Neeson - Wrath of the Titans
Though he's played men of action in the past (Darkman, Rob Roy), Liam Neeson has recently positioned himself as an elder statesman among action stars by taking the "wise mentor" role in numerous films (Batman Begins, The Phantom Menace, The A-Team) and successfully carrying several on his own (Taken, Unknown, The Grey). His character from Taken has become an iconic bad-ass of our time, perhaps even eclipsing Oskar Schindler as Neeson's most recognizable role. Neeson is a gifted actor who brings gravitas to whatever role he plays. Moreover, his characters are crafty and intelligent, approaching problems with strategy rather than relying on brute force. I think this is what sets his action films apart and what makes him an old dog, but still a top dog.

So are there any American action stars anymore? Not currently at multiplex, but there are surely more contenders to come this summer. Jennifer Lawrence racks up a modest body count in The Hunger Games. She's an underdog in the action world, though, as women are rarely cast as the leads in this genre. However, Lawrence has a convincing toughness and determination, so after the Hunger Games trilogy, who knows?

Last month, with the release of John Carter and Battleship on the horizon, Taylor "Riggins" Kitsch was looking like the new dog in Hollywood. Kitsch was one of the best things about Friday Night Lights, a TV show that had a lot of talent, but will his charisma transfer to the big screen? Unfortunately, John Carter kicked a puppy, implied that someone's mother was less than a saint, and otherwise committed crimes against humanity so reprehensible that that movie-going public staged a boycott. Oh, wait a minute, the movie didn't do any of those things! However, people still refused to see it and it is now being called the biggest flop of all time. But I'm not too worried about Kitsch just yet. Battleship looks completely ridiculous, but Liam Neeson is in it, so it can't be all bad.